On Nov. 13, routine work on the Federal Aviation Administration’s telecommunications network appears to have helped bring American air travel to a halt. Preliminary findings point to two sites: a remote radio site in Arkansas, where a contractor had deployed a new router, and a radar site in Texas. The root cause remains under investigation. A flood of connection attempts destabilized the agency’s legacy equipment, and the FAA grounded departures nationwide. Every aircraft landed safely. But a digital failure had stopped physical operations across an entire country.
Microsoft and Workday suffered major outages the same week. Officials at the FAA and Microsoft have said artificial intelligence played no role, and nothing reported links Workday’s outage to AI. Notably, the FAA had expanded a new AI system for flight planning and traffic management nationwide just three days before the ground stop; officials ruled it out as a cause. Together, though, these incidents show how routine maintenance, upgrades and testing can ripple through interconnected systems in ways their operators never anticipated.
Now consider what happens when the technology being introduced can make its own decisions, initiate its own actions and move physical machinery. This is the emerging world of physical AI.
AI Is Leaving The Screen
For most people, AI still lives on a screen. It drafts documents, answers questions and recommends decisions. When it fails, the consequences are usually financial, contractual or reputational. That is changing quickly.
Autonomous vehicles navigate public roads. Robots handle materials, operate manufacturing equipment and share warehouses with people. Intelligent systems regulate buildings’ electrical and mechanical infrastructure. Agricultural machinery works without continuous human direction. Each combines AI with sensors, mechanical equipment and physical environments that were often designed long before autonomous decision-making was practical. The potential benefits are substantial. So are the risks, because a physical AI failure can damage property, halt production or injure people in seconds.
A Failure at The Intersection
The October 2023 incident involving a Cruise robotaxi in San Francisco shows what these failures look like. A pedestrian struck by a hit-and-run driver was thrown into the robotaxi’s path. The vehicle braked and stopped, then attempted to pull over, dragging her about 20 feet because its systems did not detect that she was underneath. The failure did not sit neatly inside the AI. It arose where the software, its sensors, another driver’s actions and an unanticipated situation met.
Related: US Airlines Race to Recover From Longest Shutdown in Decades
What followed was just as instructive. Cruise’s initial reports to federal regulators omitted the dragging, which the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration identified after reviewing video it had requested. The company agreed to pay a $1.5 million NHTSA penalty and later a $500,000 criminal fine under a deferred prosecution agreement in which it admitted submitting a false report to influence a federal investigation. In physical AI, what the machine recorded, and how the company handled that record, can matter as much as what the machine did.
One Incident, Several Investigations
A significant physical AI incident cannot be understood through a single discipline. Several investigations must proceed together.
Forensic engineers determine whether sensors, mechanical components, software, electrical systems or safety controls contributed. Human factors specialists examine how people interacted with the autonomous equipment, whether warnings were adequate and whether there was a reasonable opportunity to intervene.
Digital investigators reconstruct what the machine perceived, what it decided and what commands it issued. That depends on preserving sensor readings, model versions, operating logs and telemetry before they are overwritten, sometimes within hours.
Financial experts then measure the losses: property damage, business interruption, lost profits, remediation costs and, in some cases, lasting impairment of valuable business assets.
Attorneys and insurers face the questions that follow. Was the failure foreseeable? Did it stem from a defective product, poor integration, improper maintenance or unreasonable reliance on automation? Who bears responsibility, and which policies respond? None of these can be answered without the technical record. Physical AI is creating a new category of disputes that cuts across conventional professional boundaries.
For insurers, the coverage questions may be the least settled of all. When a compromised or malfunctioning control system causes bodily injury or property damage, the loss can fall between cyber and general liability programs, and which one responds is often genuinely unsettled. An autonomous machine also raises questions conventional adjusting protocols do not answer: Can it be repaired? Must the model be retrained, at what cost and by whom? If the model itself was corrupted, is that a physical loss or a cyber loss?
The Business Case Must Include The Downside
In decades of valuing intellectual property and other intangible assets, I have seen that technology creates value only when it can be successfully deployed and sustained. The benefits of innovation must be weighed against the risks of putting it to work.
A manufacturer might justify a multimillion-dollar investment in autonomous equipment on labor savings and higher throughput. But a single preventable integration failure that causes injury or an extended shutdown could erase years of those savings. Even with insurance, the company may still absorb deductibles, uncovered losses, litigation, regulatory scrutiny and damaged customer relationships.
The business case for physical AI cannot end with whether the technology works. It must also show that the organization can operate it safely, contain failures, preserve evidence and respond when something goes wrong. That means testing interconnected systems together, setting clear limits on autonomous authority, maintaining effective human oversight, documenting every change to models and equipment, and rehearsing incident response before it is needed.
Three Questions Before Approving Capital — Or Binding Coverage
Responsible risk management should not become an excuse to delay innovation. Moving quickly and understanding downside exposure are not mutually exclusive. Before approving capital for physical AI, management and boards should require answers to three questions:
- If something goes wrong, can we reconstruct what happened, establish responsibility and measure the loss?
- Are our existing infrastructure, people and safety controls prepared for what these systems can do?
- Does our business case account for the cost of a failure, and not only the savings when everything works?
Brokers and underwriters should ask a parallel set before binding coverage: How was the system validated, and within what operating limits? Who can override it? Are incident logs retained? How are model updates and equipment changes controlled?
The organizations that answer those questions honestly will be the ones that capture the value of physical AI rather than litigate it.
Malackowski is chief intellectual property officer of J.S. Held and co-founder of Ocean Tomo, a part of J.S. Held. His work focuses on technology strategy, intellectual property, intangible asset valuation and economic damages.
Was this article valuable?
Here are more articles you may enjoy.
Miami Beach Buildings Sinking at Different Rates, Due to Construction, Study Finds
Binance Hackers Used Fake Job Interviews in $6.3 Billion Heist
Huang, Face of the AI Boom, Ousted by Nvidia Board as CEO
Microsoft Says Making Progress Fixing One of Its Longest Outages