Burke’s Law

Courts Continue to Struggle with Attorney-Client Privilege and Work-Product Doctrine

The previous year saw a number of important cases interpreting and developing the application of the attorney-client privilege and the work-product doctrine in the context of insurance claims. Insurers and insureds consistently assert and challenge these protections in coverage disputes, …

Agent Liability for Insurer Insolvency

Agents’ errors and omissions (E&O) policies provide protection for agents for certain negligent acts committed in their professional capacity but may exclude coverage for liability related to an insurer’s insolvency. These “insolvency exclusions” typically exclude coverage if the agent places …

South Dakota Court Rules Against ‘Owned-But-Not-Insured’ Exclusion

With the South Dakota Supreme Court’s decision in Wheeler v. Farmers Mut. Ins. Co. of Neb., 2012 S.D. 83, the state joined a number of other states in invalidating “owned-but-not-insured” exclusions in uninsured motorist policies. The court held that South …

Insurer Must Show Prejudice to Enforce Proof of Loss Provision in California

A California court of appeals recently determined that a proof of loss condition in a first party insurance policy is subject to the notice-prejudice rule. According to the decision, an insurer cannot avoid its coverage obligations due to a policyholder’s …

Ohio Supreme Court Determines Defective Construction is Not Covered by CGL Policy

The Supreme Court of Ohio recently held that defective construction is not an “occurrence” covered under a commercial general liability policy. The decision clarifies an issue on which lower appellate courts had been split, but the court’s broad ruling was …

Circuit Courts Affirm Strict Construction of Flood Insurance Policies

Two recent circuit court decisions affirmed that national flood insurance policies are to be strictly construed and are not subject to the flexible standards applied to private insurance policies. The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) was created because the private …

Natural Gas Driller and Insurer Dispute Coverage for Fracking Claim

One of the first lawsuits implicating insurance coverage for a fracking-related claim is under way in Ohio. Warren Drilling Co., Inc. v. ACE American Ins. Co., No. 2:12-cv-425 (S.D. Ohio 2012) will be the first case to determine how insurance …

New York Court Finds Ambiguity in Exception for Explosions

A New York appellate court recently issued one of the more interesting policy interpretation decisions, highlighting the importance of clearly drafted policies and exhibiting the well-settled principle that any ambiguity in a policy should be construed liberally in favor of …

Georgia Court Allows Insured to Recover Cost of Repair and Loss in Value

The Georgia Supreme Court recently faced the question of whether an insured could be compensated by its insurer for both the cost of repair and the diminution in value of damaged real property. The issue was one of first impression …

Third Circuit Interprets ‘Arising Out Of’ Clause for UM Benefits Broadly

For uninsured motorist coverage to apply, vehicle liability policies provide that the injury to the insured must be “caused by accident and arise out of the ownership, maintenance, or use of an uninsured auto.” The “arising out of” clause defines …

Burke’s Law Archives by Month